A few weeks ago, I watched HBO's Elizabeth I . I am a Tudor fanatic. I read probably one or two books a year connected to the time period. And I never miss an issue of Renaissance Magazine . As I don't have expensive cable I am not watching The Tudors , but I am also boycotting it in my own little way. There are MANY errors in The Tudors. Shall we start with a dark headed gent playing a redheaded king?
Helen Mirren does a fabulous job as Queen Elizabeth. She portrays Elizabeth's sense of control and yet shows the emotional ups and downs that are trials of all humans. Her portrayal of the Mary, Queen of Scots crisis is excellent. She is also a good pick for realism. When Elizabeth met the Duke of Anjou she was 48. Mirren's own maturity fits the role quite well.
Mirren, or I should say the hair people on the set, does a fabulous job of looking very similar to what we think the real Elizabeth looked like. Down to the wig she wore in her later years.
The costuming and sets are sumptuous, a veritable feast for the eyes. The attention to detail, including the special shift made for bathing and the sensors in front of the windows (Renaissance era wallflowers), is satisfying to those of us who notice these wonderful details.
One interpretation I disagreed with, was the implication that Elizabeth could not make decisions with out Robert Dudley's direction. I am not sure if the writers thought they were making Elizabeth more human, but they in fact make her appear weak. I do think there was probably an intense relationship between the two; however, I do not think that Elizabeth would have lasted long without ruling on her own. And, I believe history bears that view out.
I also do not think that her sexual abstinence is a problem. Many modern historians try to read sexual acts into her actions and relationships. Sadly, I think this comes from their own view and place in history. The large majority of Americans (and British) are promiscuous and do not enter marriage (if they ever marry) as virgins; I think this often causes historians to look back with skepticism on those who protested and championed this virtue.
The violence in the series does keep me from recommending it completely. There are extreme scenes of violence that occur without warning, including a disembowelment and a flaying.
As you can tell, I do like mimetic art; these scenes were absolutely unnecessary and quite disturbing. I will probably not watch this series again because of these scenes. If you think you can stomach these, you may enjoy this series.
Recent Comments